UNFORGETTABLE AND FORGETTABLE
AT THE SAME TIME

Well, here’s a show that, while it doesn’t defy description, is nonetheless perplexing. As with Matthew Borne’s Cinderella, now playing across town, only you can decide whether or not the convoluted goings on play second fiddle to the astounding talent and dancing on stage. Co-written with Coleman Domingo by director Patricia McGregor, Lights Out: Nat “King” Cole is a fever dream that is entertaining, terrifically intense, distancing and confusing.

Bryan Dobson as Caroler, Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole and Mary Pat Green as Caroler

Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole

I’m still trying to piece this puzzle together (if that’s possible), but I believe we are on the set of the jazz crooner’s own Nat “King” Cole show for his final taping, a 1957 Christmas show. A four-man jazz band– replicating Nelson Riddle’s orchestra–sits upstage. In his dressing room, Nat (Dulé Hill)–who died in 1965 at 45 from lung cancer–is in a foul mood.

Ruby Lewis as Betty Hudson

Connor Amacio Matthews as young Nat King Cole, Zonya Love as Perlina and Dulé Hill

He is upset that his face is whitened with powder so that he will appeal more to nationwide audiences; his pushy manager (Bryan Dobson) reminds him how far he has come as a Negro entertainer. (Cole’s real-life show, having trouble finding nationwide sponsors, aired for one year only, 1956-57; Cole refused to accept a less desirable time slot and he had grown disgusted by the racism in the advertising business: “Madison Avenue,” he is reported to have said, “is afraid of the dark.”)

Zonya Love as Perlina

Zonya Love as Perlina and Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole

Throughout the West Coast Premiere at the Geffen Playhouse, Nat is heckled by Sammy Davis Jr. (Daniel J. Watts), who acts as a sort of a tap-dancing, come-out-of-the-(race)-closet spirit guide throughout. Between red-herring non-linear scenes and astounding numbers performed by actors impersonating Eartha Kitt and Natalie Cole (Gisela Adisa), Betty Hutton and Peggy Lee (Ruby Lewis), and a young Billy Preston (Connor Amacio Matthews), I wondered if this was simply Nat at the end of his life, cataloging his thoughts about the difference he did or did not make as a black entertainer.

Gisela Adisa as Eartha Kitt

Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole and Gisela Adisa as Eartha Kitt

If not, what’s with the coughing fits, which came later in life? But if these are his final moments, why is he so perturbed? Underneath the cool, handsome exterior, is this his ruffled rage against repugnant racism? Did he not love as well? Which means this show–which is also filled with modern anachronisms–feels less about Cole and more about racism, which doesn’t dramaturgically sustain the momentum. While it has shades of All That Jazz–the film about a Broadway director in his last days–and Jelly’s Last Jam–which examines the legacy of Jelly Roll Morton, Lights Out’s thrilling parts don’t make a cohesive whole–almost intentionally so.

But, oh those parts.

Ruby Lewis as Betty Hudson and Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole

Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole and Daniel J. Watts as Sammy Davis Jr.

Well before Mr. Hill became a TV star, he tap danced on Broadway. While Nat Cole didn’t dance, Hill and Watts’s amusingly with-it, gloriously indefatigable Sammy Davis Jr. light up the stage in an extraordinary blazing tap routine choreographed by Jared Grimes (Edgar Godineaux provided other dance numbers). All the entertainers add enough uncanny vocal and physical inflections to make them wholly believable. Even Cole’s mom (devastating powerhouse Zonya Love) gets a star turn singing “Orange Colored Sky,” aided by John McDaniel‘s astute, boffo music direction.

Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole

Daniel J. Watts as Sammy Davis Jr. and Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole

When I started getting sick of those flashing applause signs egging us on, I surmised it must be intentional. Are the creators forcing us to behave on cue so we empathize with Cole? Yet the signs flashed after outstanding numbers, too. Ugh. I’m done trying to figure it out. Forget about the story. Go for the memory of Nat “King” Cole. Stay for the entertainment and nineteen remarkable songs. Continue to fight racism.

Daniel J. Watts as Sammy Davis Jr. and Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole

Gisela Adisa as young Natalie Cole and Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole

photos by Jeff Lorch

Lights Out: Nat “King” Cole
Geffen Playhouse, 10866 Le Conte Avenue in Westwood
Tues-Fri at 8; Sat at 3 & 8; Sun at 2 & 7
ends on March 10, 2019 EXTENDED to March 24, 2019
for tickets, call 310.208.5454 or visit Geffen Playhouse

Gisela Adisa as Eartha Kitt and Dulé Hill as Nat King Cole