WHO’LL GET THE TONY?
Theater Article
by Harvey Perr
published June 11, 2008
It’s that time of the year again when the country gets treated to
another spectacle about the glories of the commercial theater; when, once again, they are told that everything significant that happens in the
theater happens within a few square blocks of real estate between 42nd Street and 54th Street, between 9th Avenue and
the Avenue of the Americas; when the splash and pomp of the Broadway musical comedy reigns supreme; when the stages of all those cramped,
uncomfortable theaters seem populated by movie and television stars, some of whom are automatically rewarded for just showing up, some of whom
get even more attention for being ignored; when the serious American theater, which is really located almost everywhere else in New York City
except in that specific area, looks more and more each season like a museum, housing mostly the relics of our rich past. We complain each year, we cavil, we hope against hope that Rosie O’Donnell won’t show up and then miss her
because we sometimes feel that she may be the only one who really cares about the forlornly beautiful cadaver in our midst. And then we watch
the damned event – the presentation of the annual Antoinette Perry Awards – and we’re always surprised, given the omissions and, worse, given
the amount of junk that gets singled out in order to fill the required number of nominations in a particular category, and we are usually
surprised by how judicious most of the awards seem to be. We may even shed a tear or two because the candidates seem to be full of much truer
emotions than their counterparts in that annual awards show that emanates from
Hollywood. And sometimes we are even entertained by the snippets from the musicals that range in quality from the sublime to the
ridiculous. We may even get excited when the prizes won not by the ones who deserve it but by the ones we secretly want to win them are handed
out. It’s The Tonys!
And if Ben Brantley and Charles Isherwood of the New York Times can choose and predict their favorites, why, I ask, can’t I? So
here goes:
BEST PLAY
Will win: August:
Osage County
Should win:
Rock ‘n’
Roll
Should NOT have been nominated:
The 39
Steps
BEST MUSICAL
Will win:
Passing
Strange
Should win:
Passing
Strange
Should NOT have been nominated:
Cry-Baby
BEST PLAY REVIVAL
Will win:
Boeing-Boeing
Should win:
Boeing-Boeing
Should have been nominated:
Cat on a Hot Tin
Roof
Should NOT have been nominated:
The
Homecoming
BEST MUSICAL REVIVAL
Will win:
South
Pacific
Should win:
South
Pacific
Should NOT have been nominated:
Gypsy
BEST BOOK OF A MUSICAL
Will win:
Stew
Passing
Strange
Should win:
Stew
Passing
Strange
Guilty pleasure:
Douglas Carter Beane
Xanadu
BEST ORIGINAL SCORE
Will win:
Lin-Manuel Miranda
In The
Heights
Should win:
Stew and Heidi Rodewald
Passing
Strange
BEST ACTOR IN A PLAY
Will win:
Mark Rylance
Boeing-Boeing
Should win:
Mark Rylance
Boeing-Boeing
Should have been nominated:
Terrence Howard
Cat on a Hot Tin
Roof
and
Kevin Anderson
Come Back, Little
Sheba
BEST ACTRESS IN A PLAY
Will win:
Deanna Dunagan
August: Osage
County
Should win:
Deanna Dunagan
August: Osage
County
Should have been nominated:
Anika Noni Rose
Cat on a Hot Tin
Roof
Should have been nominated in Best Featured Actress
Category:
Amy Morton
August: Osage
County
BEST ACTOR IN A MUSICAL
Will win:
Lin-Manuel Miranda
In The
Heights
Should win:
Paulo Szot
South
Pacific
BEST ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL
Will win:
Patti Lupone
Gypsy
Should win:
Kelli O’Hara
South
Pacific
Glad they are along for the ride:
Jenna Russell
Sunday in the Park With
George
and Kerry Butler
Xanadu
BEST FEATURED ACTOR IN A PLAY
Will win:
Jim Norton
The
Seafarer
Should win:
Jim Norton or Conleth Hill
The
Seafarer
Should have been nominated:
James Earl Jones
Cat on a Hot Tin
Roof
BEST FEATURED ACTRESS IN A PLAY
Will win:
Mary McCormack
Boeing-Boeing
Should win:
Mary McCormack
Boeing-Boeing
or
Rondi Reed
August: Osage
County
Should have been nominated:
Kathryn Hahn
Boeing-Boeing
BEST FEATURED ACTOR IN A MUSICAL
Will win:
Boyd Gaines
Gypsy
Should win:
Danny Burstein
South
Pacific
or
Daniel Breaker
Passing
Strange
BEST FEATURED ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL
Will win:
Laura Benanti
Gypsy
Should win:
Laura Benanti
Gypsy
or
Loretta Ables Sayre
South
Pacific
Should have been nominated:
Mary Testa and
Jackie Hoffman
Xanadu
BEST DIRECTION OF A PLAY
Will win:
Anna D. Shapiro
August: Osage
County
Should win:
Anna D. Shapiro
August: Osage
County
BEST DIRECTION OF A MUSICAL
Will win:
Bartlett Sher
South
Pacific
Should win:
Bartlett Sher
South
Pacific
BEST CHOREOGRAPHY
Will win:
Rob Ashford
Cry-Baby
Should win:
Rob Ashford (if the award goes to a single ballet)
Cry-Baby
BEST ORCHESTRATIONS
Will win:
Stew and Heidi Rodewald
Passing
Strange
Should win:
Jason Carr
Sunday in the Park With
George
Should have been nominated:
Robert Russell Bennett (1894-1981) for his original
orchestrations
South
Pacific
BEST SCENIC DESIGN OF A PLAY
Will win:
Todd Rosenthal
August: Osage County
Should win:
Todd Rosenthal
August: Osage County
Should have been nominated:
Rae Smith
The Seafarer
BEST SCENIC DESIGN OF A MUSICAL
Will win:
Michael Yeargan
South
Pacific
Should win:
Michael Yeargan
South
Pacific
BEST COSTUME DESIGN OF A PLAY
Will win:
Katrina Lindsay
Les Liaisons
Dangereuses
Should win:
Rob Howell
Boeing-Boeing
BEST COSTUME DESIGN OF A MUSICAL
Will win:
David Farley
Sunday in the Park With
George
Should win:
David Farley
Sunday in the Park With
George
BEST LIGHTING DESIGN OF A PLAY
Will win:
Kevin Adams
The 39
Steps
Should win:
Ann G. Wrightson
August: Osage County
BEST LIGHTING DESIGN OF A MUSICAL
Will win:
Donald Holder
South
Pacific
Should win:
Donald Holder
South
Pacific
Should have been nominated:
Kevin Adams
Passing
Strange
BEST SOUND DESIGN OF A PLAY
Will win:
No guess
Should win:
Ian Dickson
Rock ‘n’
Roll
BEST SOUND DESIGN OF A MUSICAL
Will win:
No guess
Should win:
Scott Lehrer
South
Pacific
harveyperr @ stageandcinema.com
The Tony Awards will be broadcast on Sunday evening, June 15.
|